The dos and don’ts of handling suspension from the workplace

Suspension guidance for managers

It is not uncommon for an employer to consider removing an employee from the workplace during an investigation into their conduct as an “easy” solution to managing the situation, especially where they are faced with allegations that could substantially jeopardise the employer’s reputation or business interests.

Although the allegations may provide a justification for considering suspension, this does not automatically mean that doing so would be reasonable or proportionate, even where, at face value, it may appear to be the natural course of action.

The first thing to keep in mind is that the seriousness of an allegation, even where this may amount to gross misconduct, does not automatically justify suspension. Instead, an employer should have reasonable and proper grounds for taking this step, having considered the particular circumstances and whether one or more of the following risks arise:

  • There is a reasonable belief that, should the employee remain at work, they may conceal or destroy evidence, influence witnesses or otherwise interfere with the investigation;
  • There is a genuine risk of harm, whether physical or psychological, to other employees, third parties or the employee themselves if they remain at work as normal;
  • There is a significant risk to the employer’s business interests, property, operations or reputation should the employee continue working.

Additionally, even where reasonable grounds exist to support the above risks, consideration should always be given to whether there are viable alternatives to suspension that the employer could implement to reduce or manage those risks.

As such, proper consideration of these factors is essential, as employers may otherwise rush into a decision and expose themselves to legal risks that could have been avoided.

The way suspension is communicated and implemented is also of equal importance.

What can employers learn from the case law?

The importance of properly considering the decision to suspend an employee has been highlighted in several cases over the years, particularly in relation to the employer’s implied contractual duty of mutual trust and confidence.

This duty applies to all employment relationships and means that an employer must not, without reasonable and proper cause, act in a way that is likely to seriously damage or destroy the relationship of trust and confidence with its employee. As suspension can have significant consequences for an employee, including their professional reputation and wellbeing, suspending them without reasonable justification may amount to a breach of this duty.

This was demonstrated in Gogay v Hertfordshire County Council [2000], where a care worker was suspended following concerns about possible abuse involving a child.

The Court of Appeal found that the employer had acted unreasonably, particularly given the uncertainty surrounding the allegation and the manner in which the suspension had been communicated. As a result, the suspension amounted to a breach of the implied term of trust and confidence.

However, this does not mean that employers must demonstrate that suspension was the only option available to them.

In London Borough of Lambeth v Agoreyo [2019], a teacher was suspended following allegations that she had used inappropriate force against pupils. The Court of Appeal upheld the original judge’s finding that the employer had reasonable and proper cause to suspend her whilst the allegations were investigated and confirmed that the legal test is not whether suspension was absolutely necessary, but whether the employer had reasonable and proper cause for taking that decision.

The distinction between these cases is therefore an important one for employers. Whilst suspension without reasonable justification may amount to a breach of contract, employers are not required to prove that there was no possible alternative.

What matters is that the decision is supported by reasonable grounds, taking account of the circumstances and risks involved.

What does this mean in practice?

Consider an employee accused of financial misconduct who continues to have unrestricted access to financial records and systems. Suspension may be appropriate where there are reasonable concerns that evidence could be altered, concealed or destroyed.

However, if access to those systems can be temporarily restricted without preventing the employee from performing other duties, it may be more difficult to justify suspension. Similarly, where an employee is accused of bullying or harassment, an employer may reasonably be concerned about allowing the individuals involved to continue working together whilst the allegations are investigated. However, this does not automatically mean that suspension is appropriate, particularly where temporary changes to shifts, reporting lines or working arrangements could sufficiently protect those involved.

Where allegations involve violence, serious safety risks or safeguarding concerns, suspension may be more readily justified, particularly where alternative arrangements cannot adequately manage the risks.

How should employers implement suspension?

Where suspension is considered appropriate, employers should ensure that the decision is clearly explained and confirmed in writing.

Suspensions should not be used punitively; they should always be as brief as possible, kept under review, and it should be made clear to the employee that suspension does not equate to disciplinary action, or that disciplinary action may necessarily follow the investigation proceedings.

Likewise, suspension should be lifted when it is established that it is no longer necessary for the course of the investigation.

For example, if an employee was suspended due to concerns about interference with witnesses, but all relevant witness evidence has subsequently been obtained, the employer should reconsider whether there remains a reasonable justification for continuing the suspension.

What are the risks of getting it wrong?

As illustrated in the Gogay case referred to above, an unreasonable suspension may amount to a breach of the implied contractual duty of mutual trust and confidence. Depending on the circumstances, this could result in an employee resigning and pursuing a claim for constructive unfair dismissal or potentially seeking damages for breach of contract. There may also be additional risks of discrimination or whistleblowing claims where the suspension is connected to a protected characteristic, a protected act or a protected disclosure.

Importantly, the fact that an employee continues to receive their normal pay does not necessarily protect an employer against legal action. In the Gogay case, for example, the employee was entitled to damages for a recognised psychiatric injury arising from the employer’s breach of contract.

The key takeaway for employers

Whilst suspension can be a necessary and appropriate measure when managing serious workplace allegations, it should not be regarded as the default response.

Before making a decision, employers should consider what actual risks arise from allowing the employee to remain at work, whether those risks can reasonably be managed through alternative arrangements, and whether there are reasonable and proper grounds to justify suspension.

Taking the time to consider these questions, documenting the reasons for the decision and keeping any suspension under review can significantly reduce the risk of an otherwise legitimate investigation resulting in an avoidable employment dispute.

If you would like any help and support in circumstances where you are considering suspending an employee, please do get in touch – 01983 897003.

Share This Article
Read More Articles
Any questions? Contact us

Appointments are available by telephone or via video call, so no matter where you are in England or Wales we can assist you.

Leave a Reply

The information contained in this blog post is provided for guidance and is a snapshot of the law at the time it is written. It is provided for your information only and should not be used as a substitute for obtaining legal advice that it specific to your particular circumstances.

The guidance should not be relied upon in any decision making process. It is strongly recommended that you seek advice before taking action.


Solicitor in Eastleigh | Solicitor in Salisbury | Solicitor Isle of Wight