The Importance of a Well-Managed Probation Period in Light of the New Employment Rights Bill 2024

This week we saw the unveiling of the new bill that will affect many areas of employment law. One of the interesting focus points is how this will affect the management of probation periods for new employees.

With the introduction of the Employment Rights Bill 2024, the attitude and approach to probationary periods will have to undergo a transformative change. It is often wrongly perceived as an employer’s safe window of time to essentially terminate an employee with relative impunity. However, in reality how employers utilise this period of time can significantly impact both the workforce and their legal standing.

A probation period serves as a crucial time for both employers and employees. It allows employers to evaluate an employee’s performance, fit within the team, and adherence to company culture. For employees, it provides an opportunity to acclimate to the role and assess whether the organisation aligns with their career goals.

However, effective management during this period is essential. Regular check-ins and open lines of communication can foster a supportive environment. By addressing concerns early, employers can help employees understand expectations and make necessary adjustments. This proactive approach not only aids in performance improvement but also promotes job satisfaction and retention.

One of the most significant advantages of a well-managed probation period is the opportunity for timely feedback. Addressing performance issues as they arise—rather than waiting until the end of the probation period—can prevent misunderstandings and promote development.

Employers should establish a structured feedback system, incorporating regular reviews to discuss strengths and areas for improvement. This transparency can empower employees, making them feel valued and invested in their role. Furthermore, it sets the foundation for a positive working relationship, which is critical for long-term success.

The risks of not having clear paper trails and reference points of issues early on means that if allegations were raised against you as an employer this will be harder to defend. The key is building a foundation of evidence to support any decision making at the end of the probation period.

The Employment Rights Bill 2024 introduces several key changes aimed at strengthening employee protections. One of its primary focuses is on increasing job security and providing clearer pathways for addressing workplace concerns. Probation periods under the bill will include:

  1. Increased Transparency: Employers are required to provide clearer documentation of the terms of the probation period, including expectations and criteria for assessment. This helps ensure that employees understand what is required for successful completion.
  2. Regular Feedback: The bill encourages regular performance reviews during the probation period. Employers must offer constructive feedback and give employees the opportunity to address any performance issues.
  3. Rights to Appeal: Employees will have the right to appeal decisions made during or at the end of the probation period, particularly if they face dismissal. This adds a layer of protection against unfair treatment.
  4. Protection from Unfair Dismissal: The bill strengthens protections against unfair dismissal during probation. Employers need to demonstrate that any dismissal is justified based on documented performance issues.
  5. Clear Processes: The legislation outlines the need for clear processes regarding the end of the probation period, including how decisions will be communicated and what options employees have if they do not meet expectations.

These changes aim to create a fairer environment for employees, ensuring they receive the support and feedback necessary to succeed during their initial months with an employer.

This legislation underscores the importance of timely communication during probation periods. Employers are now encouraged to document any performance issues as they arise, which can help protect against potential claims related to unfair dismissal. It is pertinent to note that the bill also seeks to establish a day one right for employees from unfair dismissal. Currently, employees are required to have two years continuous service before being eligible for unfair dismissal protections.

 Inadequate handling of a probation period—such as failing to provide constructive feedback or ignoring performance issues—can lead to claims in an employment tribunal.

Failing to manage a probation period effectively can have serious repercussions. If an employee is dismissed without a clear record of performance concerns, they may argue that their dismissal was unfair or unjust. The tribunal will look for evidence of fair treatment and proper processes.

Without documented evidence of regular feedback and attempts to support the employee, an employer may find themselves in a vulnerable position. This could lead to not only legal challenges but also a damaged reputation within the industry.

In summary, a well-managed probation period is essential in fostering a productive and engaged workforce. By utilising this time to address concerns promptly and transparently, employers can minimise risks associated with potential tribunal claims, especially in light of the new Employment Rights Bill 2024.

We encourage all managers to reflect on their current practices and consider how they can enhance their approach to probation management. Let’s work together to create a supportive environment that benefits both our employees and the organisation as a whole.

Share This Article
Read More Articles
Any questions? Contact us

Appointments are available by telephone or via video call, so no matter where you are in England or Wales we can assist you.

The information contained in this blog post is provided for guidance and is a snapshot of the law at the time it is written. It is provided for your information only and should not be used as a substitute for obtaining legal advice that it specific to your particular circumstances.

The guidance should not be relied upon in any decision making process. It is strongly recommended that you seek advice before taking action.


Solicitor in Eastleigh | Solicitor in Salisbury | Solicitor Isle of Wight